‘Hardy rascals of doubtful fame’ Historical perspectives upon sealers in southern New Zealand: Ian Smith Memorial Lecture 2025

Atholl John Anderson

doi:10.70460/jpa.v15i1.378

Authors

Atholl John Anderson Australian National University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.70460/jpa.v15i1.378

Keywords:

perception and behaviour of sealers, southern New Zealand, early nineteenth century

Abstract

In paying tribute to the late Ian Smith this lecture takes up a theme arising from his interests in the exploitation of marine mammals and the early historical archaeology of southern New Zealand. The commercial sealing industry, about 1792-1830, is known from shipping and other historical records and to some extent from historical archaeology but the activities and experiences of sealers, as individuals and in their gangs, remain little known. At the same time, sealers as a class appear widely in the general historical literature where they are associated characteristically with primitive, barbaric or immoral behaviours both in New Zealand and elsewhere on the Tasman frontier. The questions at issue are whether observations of the sealers support the general description and how the latter arose. It is argued that inter-gang behaviour, skirmishing with Māori, sealer housing and diet and relationships with Māori women, do not fit the general description nor do sealers stand out in these respects from whalers or other European sojourners. It is suggested that the characterisation of New Zealand sealers owes much to the flow of opinion about sealers across the Tasman world and an historiography of social evolution.

References

Anderson A. 1981. A model of prehistoric collecting on the rocky shore. Journal of Archaeological Science. 8:109-120. DOI: 10.1016/0305-4403(81)90020-0 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0305-4403(81)90020-0

Anderson A. 1991. Race Against Time: the early Maori-Pakeha families and the development of the mixed-race population in southern New Zealand. Hocken Lecture 1990. Hocken Library, University of Otago.

Anderson, A. 2017. Historical characterisation of ‘the very scum of Port Jackson’. Te Rau Aroha marae wanaka 17th August. Unpublished.

Anderson, A.J. 2023. Seafaring and colonization in the Southern Ocean, 1000 CE-1850 CE. In R.T. Jones & M.K. Matsuda (eds) The Pacific Ocean to 1800. The Cambridge History of the Pacific Ocean Vol. I: 457-479. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/9781108539272.026 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108539272.026

Anderson A. & I. Smith. 1992. The Papatowai Site: new evidence and interpretations. Journal of the Polynesian Society 101: 129-158.

Anderson A. & I. Smith. 1996. The transient village in southern New Zealand. World Archaeology 27: 359-371. DOI: 10.1080/00438243.1996.9980314 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00438243.1996.9980314

Anderson, A., Allingham B., & Smith, I. (eds) 1996. Shag River Mouth: the Archaeology of an Early Southern Maori Village, pp. 185-199. Canberra, ANU Press, Research Papers in Archaeology and Natural History, No. 27.

Anderson A., Smith I., & White, P. 2001. Archaeological fieldwork on Norfolk Island. In A. Anderson & White P. (eds), The Prehistoric Archaeology of Norfolk Island, Southwest Pacific, Supplement 27, Records of the Australian Museum, Sydney, 11-32. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3853/j.0812-7387.27.2001.1336

Anderson A., Conte E., Smith I. & K. Szabó. 2019. New Excavations at Fa'ahia (Huahine, Society Islands) and Chronologies of Colonization in Central East Polynesia. Journal of Pacific Archaeology. 10: 1-14. DOI: 10.70460/jpa.v10i1.279 DOI: https://doi.org/10.70460/jpa.v10i1.279

Ballantyne, Tony 2012, Webs of Empire: locating New Zealand’s colonial past. Wellington: Bridget Williams Books. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7810/9781927131435

Brett, A. 2017. Australia and the secretive exploitation of the Chatham Islands to 1842. Journal of Australian Studies. 41: 96-112. DOI: 10.1080/14443058.2016.1275745 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14443058.2016.1275745

Cahir, F. and Clark, I.D. 2014. The Maori presence in Victoria, Australia, 1830-1900: a preliminary analysis of Australian sources. New Zealand Journal of History, 48: 109-126.

Capie, D. 2009. New Zealand and the world: imperial, international and global relations. In G. Byrnes (ed.) The New Oxford History of New Zealand. Melbourne: Oxford University Press: 573-598.

Church, I. 2008. Gaining a Foothold: historical records of Otago’s eastern coast 1770-1839. Dunedin: Friends of the Hocken Collections.

Clarke, G. Jr. 1903. Notes on Early Life in New Zealand. Hobart.

Collins, CJ., Rawlence N.J., Prost S., Anderson C.N.K., Knapp, M., Scofield R.P., Robertson B.C., Smith I., Matisoo-Smith E.A., Chilvers B.L. & Waters, J.M. 2014. Extinction and recolonization of coastal megafauna following human arrival in New Zealand. Proc. R. Soc. B. 281: 20140097. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2014.0097

Coutts, P.J.F. 1985. Towards the development of colonial archaeology in New Zealand. Part2: early settlement patterns in southern New Zealand. Australian Historical Archaeology 3: 31-42.

Cuneen, M & Allbrook, M. 2023. Understanding convict lives: an historiographical and methodological assessment. Australian Journal of Biography and History 7: 3-21. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22459/AJBH.07.2023.01

Dieffenbach, E. 1843. Travels in New Zealand, vol 1. London: Murray.

Entwisle, P. 1998. Behold the Moon: the European occupation of the Dunedin district 1770-1848. Dunedin: Port Daniel Press.

Entwisle, P. 2005. Taka: a vignette life of William Tucker 1784-1817. Dunedin: Port Daniel Press.

Dow, G.K. & C.G. Reed, 2023. Economic Prehistory: six transitions that shaped the world. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108878142

Flexner, J.L. 2020. Vale Ian W.G. Smith (1954-2020). Australian Historical Archaeology 38: 83-87.

Gill, J.C.H. 1967. Notes on the sealing industry in early Australia. Journal of the Royal Historical Society of Queensland 8: 218-245.

Grosser, S., Rawlence, N.J., Anderson, C.N.K., Smith, I.W.G., Scofield, R.P. & Waters, J.M. 2016. Invader or resident? Ancient-DNA reveals rapid species turnover in New Zealand little penguins. Proceedings of the Royal Society. 283: 20152879. DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2015.2879 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2015.2879

Higham, C. F. W. 1976. The economic basis of the Foveaux Straits Maori in prehistory. In Sieveking, G. de G., Longworth, I.H. & Wilson K.E. (eds) Problems in Economic and Social Archaeology. London: Duckworth: 221-233.

Howard, B. 1940. Rakiura: a history of Stewart Island, New Zealand. Dunedin: Reed.

Leach, B.F. 1976. Prehistoric Communities in Palliser Bay, New Zealand. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Otago.

Leach, B.F., Davidson, J.M., McCallum, G., Partridge, B., Smith, I.W.G. & Whitehead, N. 1979. The Identification of Dugong Ivory Reel Artefacts from Strontium Content and Microstructure. New Zealand Journal of Archaeology. 1: 115-121.

Leach H. 1969. Subsistence Patterns in Prehistoric New Zealand. Otago Studies in Prehistoric Anthropology 2.

Lester, A. 2006. Colonial networks, Australian humanitarianism and the history wars. Geographical Research 44: 229-241. DOI: 10.1111/j.1745-5871.2006.00387.x DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-5871.2006.00387.x

Maxwell, J. & Smith, I. 2015, A reassessment of settlement patterns and subsistence at Point Durham, Chatham Island. Archaeology in Oceania. 50(3): 162-174. DOI: 10.1002/arco.5062 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/arco.5062

McLintock, A.H. 1949. The History of Otago. Dunedin: Whitcombe and Tombs

McNab, R. 1909. Murihiku, a history of the South Island of New Zealand etc. Wellington: Whitcombe and Tombs.

Merry, K. 2003. The cross-cultural relationships between the sealers and Tasmanian Aboriginal women at Bass Strait and Kangaroo Island in the early nineteenth century. Counterpoints 3: 80-88.

Middleton, A. 2007.Two Hundred Years on Codfish Island (Whenuahou). Invercargill: Department of Conservation.

Moon, P. 2012. A Savage Country: the untold story of New Zealand in the 1820s. Auckland: Penguin.

Morgan, L. H. 1877. Ancient Society or Researches in the Lines of Human Progress from Savagery through Barbarism to Civilization. London: MacMillan.

Morton, H. 1982. The Whale’s Wake. Dunedin: Otago University Press.

Olssen, E. 1984. A History of Otago. Dunedin: John McIndoe.

Parsons, D.M., Morrison, M., Macdiarmid, A.B., Stirling B., Cleaver, P., Smith, I. & Butcher, M. 2009. Risks of shifting baselines highlighted by anecdotal accounts of New Zealand's snapper (Pagrus auratus) fishery. New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 43: 965-983. DOI: 10.1080/00288330909510054 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00288330909510054

Phillips, J. 2006. Sealing – the sealers. Te Ara: the Encyclopaedia of New Zealand. www.govt.nz/en

Plomley, N.J. B., and Henley, K.A. 1990. The sealers of Bass Strait and the Cape Barren Island community. Papers and Proceedings of the Australian National University: 37-126.

Prickett, N.J. 2002. The Archaeology of New Zealand Shore Whaling. Wellington: Department of Conservation.

Prickett, N.J. 2008. Trans-Tasman stories: Australian Aborigines in New Zealand sealing and shore whaling. In G. Clark, F. Leach and S. O'Connor (eds) Islands of Inquiry: colonisation, seafaring and the archaeology of maritime landscapes. Terra Australis 29: 351-366. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22459/TA29.06.2008.22

Rawlence, N.J., Perry, G.L.W., Smith, I.W.G., Scofield, R.P., Tennyson, A.J.D., Matisoo-Smith, E.A., Boessenkool, S., Austin, J.J. & Waters, J.M. 2015. Radiocarbon-dating and ancient DNA reveal rapid replacement of extinct prehistoric penguins. Quaternary Science Reviews 112:59-65. DOI: 1016/j.quascirev.2015.01.011 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2015.01.011

Richards, R. 1982. Whaling and Sealing at the Chatham Islands. Canberra, Roebuck.

Russell, L. 2018. Looking out to sea: indigenous mobility and engagement in Australia’s coastal industries. In R. Standfield (ed) Indigenous mobilities: across and beyond the Antipodes. Canberra: ANU Press: 165-183 DOI: https://doi.org/10.22459/IM.06.2018.07

Ryan, l. 1977. The struggle for recognition: part-Aborigines in Bass Strait in the nineteenth century. Aboriginal History 1-2:27-51. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22459/AH.01.2011.02

Salis, T., Easton, L.J., Robertson, B.C., Gemmell, N., Smith, I.W.G., Weisler, M.I., Waters, J.M & Rawlence, N.J. 2016. Myth or relict: Does ancient DNA detect the enigmatic Upland seal? Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 97: 101-106. DOI: 10.1016/j.ympev.2015.12.012 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ympev.2015.12.012

Salmond, A. 1997. Between Worlds: early exchanges between Maori and Europeans 1773-1815. Auckland: Viking.

Smith, I.W.G. 1976. Prehistoric Fur Seal Exploitation on the South-West Coast of Chatham Island. B.A.Hons. Otago. DOI: https://doi.org/10.63172/337145ccuwtz

Smith, I.W.G. 1978. Seasonal Sea Mammal Exploitation and Butchering Patterns in an Archaic Site (Tairua, N44/2) on the Coromandel Peninsula. Records of the Auckland Institute and Museum 15: 17-26.

Smith, I.W.G. 1979. Prehistoric sea mammal hunting in Palliser Bay. In Prehistoric Man in Palliser Bay. B.F. Leach and H.M. Leach eds. Wellington, National Museum of New Zealand Bulletin 21. Pages 215 – 249.

Smith, I.W.G. 1981a. Mammalian Fauna from an Archaic Site on Motutapu Island, New Zealand. Records of the Auckland Institute and Museum 18: 95-105.

Smith, I.W.G. 1981b. Prehistoric Mammalian Fauna from the Coromandel Peninsula. Records of the Auckland Institute and Museum 18: 107-125.

Smith I.W.G. 1985. Sea Mammal Hunting and Prehistoric Subsistence in New Zealand. Ph.D. thesis, Otago.

Smith, I.W.G. 1989, Maori Impact on the Marine Megafauna: Pre-European Distributions of New Zealand Sea Mammals. In D. G. Sutton (ed.) Saying So Doesn’t Make It So: Papers in Honour of B. Foss Leach. NZAA Monograph 17: 76-108.

Smith, I.W.G. 1990. Historical archaeology in New Zealand: a review and bibliography. New Zealand Journal of Archaeology 12: 85-119.

Smith, I.W.G. 1991b. The development of historical archaeology in New Zealand, 1921-1990. Australian Journal of Historical Archaeology 9: 6-13.

Smith, I.W.G. 1996. Historical documents and 18th century seal hunting in New Zealand. In J.M. Davidson, G. Irwin, B.F. Leach, A. Pawley & D. Brown eds. Oceanic Culture History: Essays in Honour of Roger Green. Dunedin, New Zealand Journal of Archaeology Special Publication: 675-688.

Smith, I.W.G. 2000. Terrestrial Fauna from Excavations at the Kainapirina (SAC) Locality, Watom Island, Papua New Guinea. New Zealand Journal of Archaeology 20(1998): 137-147.

Smith, I.W.G. 2002. The New Zealand Sealing Industry: History, Archaeology and Heritage Management. Wellington: Department of Conservation.

Smith, I.W.G. 2004. Archaeologies of identity: Historical archaeology for the 21st century. In Furey, L. & Holdaway, S. (eds.), Change Through Time: 50 years of New Zealand Archaeology. NZAA Monograph 26, pp. 251-262.

Smith, I.W.G. 2005. Retreat and resilience: fur seals and human settlement in New Zealand. In The Exploitation and Cultural Importance of Sea Mammals. G. Monks ed. Oxford, Oxbow Books pp. 6-18.

Smith, I.W.G. 2008a. Mammalian fauna from Taumako. In Leach, F. and Davidson, J. M. (eds) The archaeology of Taumako: a Polynesian outlier in the Eastern Solomon Islands. Pp. 401-405. New Zealand Journal of Archaeology Special Publication.

Smith, I.W.G. 2008b. Maori, Pakeha and Kiwi: Peoples, cultures and sequence in New Zealand archaeology. In G. Clark, F. Leach & S. O’Connor (eds.) Islands of Inquiry: Colonisation, Seafaring and the Archaeology of Maritime Landscapes. ANU EPress, Canberra. pp. 367-380. DOI: 10.22459/TA29.06.2008.23 DOI: https://doi.org/10.22459/TA29.06.2008.23

Smith, I.W.G. 2009. Mammalian Fauna from Sandy Bay, Auckland Islands. Appendix F. In Furey, L., Holdaway, S., Dingwall, P.R., Jones, K.L. & Egerton, R. (eds). In care of the Southern Ocean: an archaeological and historical survey of the Auckland Islands. New Zealand Archaeological Association Monograph 27.

Smith, I. 2013a. Pre-European Maori exploitation of marine resources in two New Zealand case study areas: species range and temporal change. Journal of the Royal Society of New Zealand 43(1):1-37. DOI: 10.1080/03036758.2011.574709 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03036758.2011.574709

Smith, I. 2013b. Ephemeral foundations: early European settlement of the Tasman frontier. In Campbell, M., Holdaway, S.J. & Macready, S. (eds). Finding our Recent Past: Historical Archaeology in New Zealand. Pp. 9-32. New Zealand Archaeological Association Monograph No. 29.

Smith, I.W.G. 2019. Pākehā settlements in a Māori world: New Zealand archaeology, 1769-1860. Bridget Williams Books, Wellington. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7810/9780947492489

Smith, I.W.G. & Anderson, A.J. 1998. Radiocarbon Dates from Archaeological Rat Bones: the Pleasant River Case. Archaeology in Oceania 33(2): 88-91. DOI: j.1834-4453.1998.tb00408.x DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1834-4453.1998.tb00408.x

Smith, I. & Anderson, A. 2009. An Archaeological Sequence for Codfish Island (Whenua Hou), Southland, New Zealand. New Zealand Journal of Archaeology, 30: 5–21.

Starke, J. (ed.) 1986. Journal of a Rambler: the journal of John Boultbee. Auckland: Oxford University Press.

Stuart, I. 1997. Sea rats, bandits and roistering buccaneers: What were the Bass Strait sealers really like? Journal of the Royal Australian Historical Society 83: 47-58.

Sutton, D.G. 1979. Polynesian coastal hunters in the subantarctic zone. PhD dissertation, University of Otago.

Tapp, E.J. 1958. Early New Zealand: a dependency of New South Wales. Melbourne University Press.

Taylor, R. 2000. Savages or saviours? – the Australian sealers and aboriginal Tasmanian survival. Journal of Australian Studies 24:73-84. DOI: 10.1080/14443050009387613 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14443050009387613

Travers, R. 1968. The Tasmanians: the story of a doomed race. Melbourne

Wakefield, E.J. 1845. Adventure in New Zealand, from 1839 to 1844 etc., Vol. 1. London: Murray.

Walter, R. & Smith, I. 1998. Identification of a New Zealand fur seal (Arctocephalus forsteri) bone in a Cook Island archaeological site. New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 32(3):483-487.

Wanhalla, A. 2009. In/visible Sight: the mixed-descent families of southern New Zealand. Wellington: Bridget Williams Books. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7810/9781877242434

Wanhalla, A. 2018. Indigenous women, marriage and colonial mobility. In R. Standfield (ed) Indigenous mobilities: across band beyond the Antipodes. Canberra: ANU Press: 209-231 DOI: https://doi.org/10.22459/IM.06.2018.09

Warneke, R.M. 2019. John William Anderson, a 'Black man' and Robert Gamble, from England, sealing in the 1830s among the islands of the Recherche Archipelago, south-western Australia. Histories of Sealing in Australia, no. 9.

Wohlers, J.F.H. 1895. Memories of the Life of J F H Wohlers, Missionary at Ruapuke, New Zealand. Dunedin: Otago Daily Times